Here's information on how Far UVC is being used and the latest developments in this space.
Not all Covid transmission engineering controls reduce the risk adequately. This infographic illustrates the relative differences between the popular engineering controls.
| 222nm UV-C Sanitation Lighting | Portable Air Cleaner - with HEPA Filters | Upgraded HVAC System- 6 ACH, no HEPA | |
| Coverage | Air + Exposed high contact surfaces | Air only | Air only |
| Ideal setting | Very high occupancy | Low occupancy | High occupancy |
| Disinfection effectiveness | 99.90% | 90% | 80% |
| Equivalent ACH | >100 | <3 | 6 |
| Time to achieve effectiveness | 1 – 10 minutes | 30 – 120 minutes | 60 – 240 minutes |
| Risk of spreading airborne pathogens | None | High | High |
| Capital cost | Low | Low | High to very high |
| Operating cost | Very low | Moderate | Extremely high |
| Ease of deployment | Easy | Very easy | Complicated |
| Time to implement | 1 – 10 days | 1 – 10 days | More than 4 months |
| Reliability | Fully automatic, unattended continuous operation | Semi automatic, attended non-continuous operation | Fully automatic, unattended continuous operation |
| Maintenance interval | 2 years | 6 months | 6 months |
| Energy consumption | Very low | Moderate | Extremely high |
| Noise level | Silent | 21 – 54 dBa | 40 – 60 dBa |
| 222nm UV-C Sanitation Lighting | 254nm UV-C Robot | Upper Room UVGI | Pulsed Xenon | |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
| Coverage | Air + Exposed high contact surfaces | Air + Exposed high contact surfaces | Air only | Air + Exposed high contact surfaces |
| Light wavelength | 221 - 223 nm | 240 - 320 nm | 240 - 320 nm | 100 - 400 nm |
| Ideal setting | Very high occupancy | No humans present | Low occupancy | No humans present |
| Disinfection effectiveness | >99% | >99% | >99% | >99% |
| Operating effectiveness | Very high | Only effective when in use | Moderate | Only effective when in use |
| Utilisation | Always on. Sanitises entire space | Sanitises only where & when device operates | Sanitises only the air void 2.3m above the floor | Sanitises only where & when device operates |
| Trained operator required | No | Yes | No | Yes |
| Noise level | Silent | Negligible | Low fan hum | Moderate |
| Precautions | None | Must include sensors & controls to prevent light reaching people | Must be specifically designed to prevent light reaching people | Light flashes can affect some people |
| Ozone generation | None | None | None | Small amount |
| Ease of deployment | Easy | Moderate | Complicated | Moderate |
| INFECTION TRANSMISSION MITIGATION - DEVICE COMPARISON | ||
| 222nm UV-C Sanitation Lighting | 405nm UV-C Sanitation Lighting | |
| Coverage | Air + Exposed high contact surfaces | Air + Exposed high contact surfaces |
| Ideal setting | Where people are present - Very high occupancy | Where people are present - Low occupancy |
| Continuous Active Disinfection | Yes | Yes |
| Method of disinfection | Two principles: Destroys DNA and Proteins of microorganisms | One principle only: Destroys the Porphryrin in the cell membrane of microorganisms. |
| Possibility of photo-reactivation | No possibility | There is a possibility of photo-reactivation of bacteria, since some bacteria have a mechanism to repair DNA. Photolyase enzyme allows for DNA repair in the light wavelength between 310 and 450nm. |
| Equivalent ACH | >100 | Not yet determined |
| Time to achieve effectiveness | 1 – 10 minutes | >120 minutes |
| Visible light | None | Visible blue light. Blue light and white light that contains blue light is proven to disrupt circadian rhythms. |
| UV Dosage control | Built in sensor and controller that ensures full compliance with the TLV's of ACGIH, Directive 2006/25/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council and Danish Working Environment Authority | None |
| Energy consumption | 17 Watts | 30 Watts |
| 222nm UV-C Sanitation Lighting | Covid | Covid | |
| Antivirals | Vaccines | ||
| Reduces hospitalizations | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Reduces transmissions | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Destroys virus in air | Yes | No | No |
| Destroys virus on surfaces | Yes | No | No |
| Usage | As a preventer | After infection | As a preventer |
| Effective against other viruses | Yes | No | No |
| Effective against bacteria | Yes | No | No |
| Protects many people per utilization | Yes | No | No |
| Cost per capita | Low | Very high | Moderate |
| Ease of deployment | Easy | Easy | Complicated |
| Reliability | Very high | High | Diminishes over time |
UVGI - Ultra Violet Germicidal Irradiation lamps fitted in HVAC systems typically use UV-C lamps that emit UV light having a wavelength of 250 - 265 nanometers (nm). This wavelength range is harmful to eyes and skin, hence it alway used in a manner that prevent direct exposure to humans.
UV-C disinfection robot for example use 254nm lamps in combination with very sophisticated sensor and control systems that shuts off the lamps as soon as a human is detected within it’s operating proximity.
Other areas of use include enclosed cabinet with safety electrical interlocks prevents the lamp for turning on while the cabinet is open.
In recents time these lamps have also been installed into HVAC systems. However, it’s neither simple nor inexpensive. A UV-C light system for installation into HVAC equipment need to be carefully designed, installed and fitted with safety systems. A common place to fit 254nm UV-C lamps is at the air-on side of HX coils. The main advantage being the prevention of mold growth. However, the residence time in this zone for infectious virus is too short. Viruses have a particle size range of 20-500nm, whereas bacteria and mold are at least twice the size.
The combination of viruses being so small and the air speed approaching the HX coils, means air borne viruses at the point don’t get a sufficiently large enough UV dose to kill them.
A better place to effectively kill Coronavirus would be in long sections of UV-C irradiated ducting where the air speed is low enough to deliver optimum residence time. After all, the effectiveness of UV-C is largely a function of UV-C light intensity multiplied by the time is exposed to the light.
The cost of retro-fitting UVGI lamps into HVAC ducting and providing appropriate safe access for lamp replacement is in many cases not the most cost effective solution. Particularly considering that only air is being sanitised. And only when the A/C is actually operating. To achieve constant air sanitation the A/C will need to operated all the time, which would increase the site’s operating cost.
Furthermore, infection transmission via contact surfaces, especially in high usage common areas, is not addressed.
On the other hand, 222 UV-C sanitises the air at the same time it sanitises the exposed surfaces. Thus making it substantially more effective at reducing infection transmission. In addition to sanitising air and surfaces simultaneously, 222 UV-C devices use significantly less energy. They are less expensive to acquire and install. The can be strategically positioned to prioritise the highest risk zones. They have a lower opex.